MSNBC's Touré on Cornel West's Thoughts About President Obama

4798It's becoming less and less fashionable to say it, but I still love Cornel West. We've been friends for over 15 years and during most of that time he has been a crucial American voice. But it's sad how he's damaged his image as an important thinker because of a series of attacks on President Obama and on other black intellectuals who have not been as critical of Obama such as Michael Eric Dyson and Melissa Harris-Perry and Reverend Sharpton. West's critique is draped in rhetoric so inflammatory that it almost disqualifies itself from being taken seriously and risks him sounding like a rapper enmeshed in a battle. In his latest salvo earlier this week, he called the President a "Rockefeller Republican in blackface."
There's nothing wrong with critiquing the President, but the reference to blackface is a verbal Molotov cocktail. And it doesn't even make sense: if Obama's in blackface then he's performing a grotesque caricature of blackness that is a white fantasy of a harmless, docile black person. Is that what he's doing? Is Obama not the opposite of that as a calm, dignified, intellectual alpha male? I'm not really sure why blackface was mentioned or what it's supposed to mean unless it's a way of calling Obama an Oreo--black on the outside and white on the inside. But that's just a guess. Earlier this year, West told TruthDig that Obama is "a black mascot of Wall Street oligarchs and a black puppet of corporate plutocrats." I'm not sure why race is even injected into that critique.

But I think calling Obama a Republican was intended to be the more devastating part of West's comment, as if being a black Republican was akin to a sellout. This makes sense given the GOP's penchant for policies that are hostile to black and brown people (anti-affirmative action, anti-social safety nets, anti-immigration, anti-DREAM act, pro-voter ID, pro tax cuts for the wealthy). But Obama has hardly been a traditional liberal. In many ways, he's more of a moderate or at least someone who draws from ideas on both sides of the aisle. West is correct in calling Obama's fiscal policy conservative-friendly: he's bailed out banks instead of prosecuting bankers, and extended the Bush tax cuts, and, in the 2011 debt ceiling talks, offered to make deep cuts to entitlements, especially Medicare. Obama's foreign policy has also often been decidedly conservative: he supported a surge in Afghanistan, escalated drone attacks which have resulted in considerable collateral damage, and ordered the extrajudicial killings of Americans who were at war with America. These are all decisions that would have the left howling if made by President Bush.

But to say that Obama's a Republican ignores a tremendous amount of data and makes a simplistic assessment of a nuanced situation. Obama achieved the decades old liberal dream of universal health care (albeit with a conservative concept, the individual mandate, at its core, rather than the liberal single-payer concept). He lowered taxes on the poorest fifth of Americans by 80%. He used the Justice Department to defend affirmative action to the Supreme Court. He signed an executive order blocking deportations of undocumented young immigrants (albeit after deporting well over a million Hispanics, moving them out at a faster rate than Bush.) He ended Don't Ask, Don't Tell and publicly supported marriage equality. And perhaps most importantly he nominated two Supreme Court justices who will defend a woman's right to choose. With that sort of record Obama would get trounced in a Republican primary.


Source: TIME Magazine 

Touré is the author of four books, including Who's Afraid of Post-Blackness? and the co-host of MSNBC's The Cycle. The views expressed are solely his own.
COMMENTS
blog comments powered by Disqus

Synergize4
Pastors & Leadership Conference 2014

NewsOne Now with Roland Martin

Kings of Christian Comedy

Christian Convocation and Chapel Speakers